• Scratch Made
  • Posts
  • The Problem With Complexity Isn’t Complexity

The Problem With Complexity Isn’t Complexity

It’s okay to be a beginner.

I’ve advised clients for almost twenty-two years, and if you stay in this business long enough you realize something simple: complexity itself isn’t the enemy. People assume it is. They hear the word and imagine clutter, confusion, unnecessary layers.

But complexity is neutral. Sometimes it’s even good. It’s a byproduct of growth, responsibility, ambition. It shows up when your life gets bigger, when your decisions carry more weight, when the stakes shift from “What do I want?” to “What does this decision set in motion?”

The problem with complexity begins when we invite it in too early.

In 2012, when I decided to train for triathlons, I spent hours obsessively researching GPS watches. It was my first season, and I treated the decision like it would determine my entire athletic future. I read reviews, compared battery life, studied waterproof ratings. Eventually I bought the watch that was considered “the best” at the time.

And it was fine. But it wasn’t what I needed.

I wasn’t good enough yet for the difference to matter.

I could barely swim in a straight line. I didn’t know how transitions worked. I didn’t understand pacing. I didn’t need the Cadillac of watches. I needed something that told me how far I went and roughly how fast.

Ironically, when I did get good, I realized the watch I chose wasn’t right for me at all.

My early obsession didn’t help me advance. It distracted me from the basics that actually would have.

It’s a pattern I see everywhere: we crave advanced solutions before we’ve mastered the simple ones.

Yesterday, I was skiing at Keystone. I was riding a gondola and shared it with four guys visiting from Utah. They all work in the ski industry. We were halfway off the ground when they asked what I do for a living. When I said I was a financial advisor, they laughed and said they had just been talking about their 401(k)s.

Their questions sounded familiar:

  • What’s the right amount to save?

  • Which funds are best?

  • Is there an ideal strategy?

All good questions.

So instead of answering directly, I asked them something in return. I told them this is only my third season on skis and asked what the best skis, boots, and goggles money could buy would be for me.

They didn’t hesitate. They said that once I was comfortable on black diamonds, I’d know exactly what I needed my gear to do. Right now it would be a waste of time.

I smiled and said, “That’s exactly my advice for your 401(k). If you aren’t saving anything, start. If you’re saving some, save more. Once you’ve got a few years of consistent saving, you’ll know what the next right move is.”

Don’t add complexity until you understand why you need it.

There’s a natural order to decision-making. Most problems have a simple foundation and a complex ceiling. But we mix the two up. We want the ceiling immediately. We want the perfect strategy, the best structure, the optimized plan. All before we’ve built the foundation that would make those advanced decisions meaningful.

It’s human nature. We want to feel like we’re doing the smart thing. We want to skip the awkward beginner phase. We want expertise without the years required to earn it.

But the truth is simple: the right strategy is contextual. It depends on where you are in your learning curve.

You don’t choose skis the way a professional ski tech chooses skis. You don’t pick a triathlon watch the way an Ironman coach picks one. And you don’t build a portfolio the way a pension fund does.

At the beginning, you pick the thing that removes friction. Later, you pick the thing that enhances performance. Eventually, you pick the thing that reflects mastery.

Each phase builds on the one before it.

And here’s the irony:

By the time complexity genuinely helps you, it no longer feels complex. It feels appropriate.

Those ski guys didn’t skip the question because they didn’t know the answer. They skipped it because they knew too much. They knew the best gear in the world won’t make a beginner better.

The same is true of wealth. People obsess over the wrong tools because they’re trying to solve a problem they haven’t earned yet. They want answers that belong to a later chapter of their story.

The work is simpler than we want it to be

Start.
Do it again tomorrow.
Let time compound the things you control.
Only add complexity once you’re ready to understand what it’s actually for.

Because in the end, the danger isn’t complexity.
The danger is believing complexity will save you before consistency will.